Home Depot (HD 0.27%) has long been a mainstay of the home improvement business, offering all kinds of products and services for a wide spectrum of customers. That includes everyone from weekend DIY warriors to professional contractors. And that’s also evolved to include both in-store and online sales — aiming to give customers the most convenient options.

It’s been a winning formula, and the home improvement giant’s history of robust results might make it seem like a no-brainer choice for shareholders. Still, it’s always a good idea to review the latest results to see if this retail giant remains a smart bet in the ever-shifting home improvement market.

The balancing of tickets and transactions

In the realm of retail, two critical metrics often dictate success: the average ticket size (the average amount customers spend per transaction) and the number of transactions. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Home Depot witnessed a surge in both metrics. CEO Ted Decker noted in the recent earnings call that the company saw a 25% increase in comparable store sales (comps), a key indicator of retail health during that time.

However he also notes that as inflation has started to ease, particularly in commodities, there’s been a noticeable dip in ticket size. The third quarter of this year saw a greater than 3% decrease in comp store sales versus the previous year. For investors, this shift signals a need to monitor how Home Depot balances these metrics in a post-pandemic, inflation-adjusted market. Part of the most recent outlook revision may well be due to this drawback and expectations of weaker demand in the near future.

Focusing on the “complex Pro”

Home Depot’s strategy significantly trends toward catering to professional contractors and specifically targets the “complex Pro” segment. Decker notes this segment represents a substantial $200 billion opportunity within the broader $950 billion home improvement market. The company’s focus here is not just about expanding its customer base but also about increasing the average transaction size. Professional projects typically involve larger and more expensive purchases, making them a lucrative target. This strategic shift suggests a potential for sustained revenue growth, especially as the company captures more market share in this lucrative segment.

Considering the macroeconomic environment

The broader economic environment, including factors like Federal Reserve policies and interest rates, plays a significant role in Home Depot’s performance. The company’s executives note a trend of customers deferring larger projects due to the current economic situation, which includes higher interest rates. This trend could impact the demand for big-ticket items, which remain a key revenue driver for Home Depot. Investors must carefully watch these key economic indicators and consumer spending trends. They’ll likely influence the company’s performance in the near future.

Weathering the current economic storm

While Home Depot has shown resilience in its storied history, the company is not immune to economic downturns or challenges with demand. The potential for a continued economic slowdown or a shift in consumer spending could dampen growth prospects. Additionally, the reliance on the complex Pro segment, while strategic, also poses risks if this market segment contracts or faces its own economic challenges (which could include labor shortages).

To mitigate these risks, Home Depot continues to diversify its offerings and invest in innovation. This includes expanding its online presence and enhancing in-store experiences to attract a broader customer base. The company’s agility in adapting to market changes and its robust supply chain are key factors that could help it navigate through uncertain economic waters.

A calculated hold, if not a no-brainer, for forward-thinking investors

For investors eyeing Home Depot as a potential addition to their portfolio, the current landscape trends toward a wait-and-see approach. The company’s strong market position, strategic focus on the complex Pro segment, and its ability to adapt to changing market dynamics are compelling reasons for optimism. However, the macroeconomic environment and its impact on consumer spending warrant a cautious approach.

The no-brainer recommendation is to hold while keeping a keen eye on how Home Depot navigates these challenges. For those considering a pickup, watching for potential dips in the stock price amid market fluctuations could present an opportunity. Home Depot, with its solid fundamentals and strategic market positioning, remains a strong contender for a long-term hold in an investor’s portfolio.

Nicholas Robbins has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Home Depot. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.